Guide

PHI Mask vs. e-discovery redaction tools

Redaction inside a review platform, desktop software, a web service, or a batch priced by the page. What each needs first, and which fits a large production.

Last reviewed

Redaction in litigation is usually done inside a review platform, by reviewers, document by document. That works when the set is already hosted and a review team is already reading it. It is slow and costly when the job is only to take personal details out of a large set before it is produced or shared.

Redaction inside a review platform

Relativity and Everlaw are review platforms, and redaction is one feature of each. Relativity's Redact is an application you install in a workspace. Its automated projects are documented as rules: words, terms and regular expressions, with patterns for values such as Social Security and card numbers. It redacts spreadsheets on the native file. The platform is priced by committed data volume, by request.

Everlaw offers batch redaction by common patterns and by search, redacts spreadsheets in the native view, and burns redactions in when a production runs. In both products the redaction lives where the review lives, which is the point: the same people who code a document for privilege redact it.

Standalone redaction software

CaseGuard is software you install, for video, audio, documents and images. It detects categories of personal, payment and health information, is licensed by the user, and its makers also offer to do the redaction for you. Redactable is a web service that redacts PDFs and images, with other files saved as PDF first, on a monthly allowance of documents, and it can build a privilege log.

Side by side

Kind of toolExampleWhat you need firstHow it is pricedWhere the files are
Review platformRelativity, EverlawThe platform, with the set loaded and a review team in itThe platform's price, on requestIn the platform
Desktop softwareCaseGuardA licence for each person who redactsBy the userOn your machines
Web serviceRedactableAn account and a planBy the document, each monthOn the vendor's service
Batch servicePHI Mask BatchA page count and a rule setBy the page, printed on the pageIn your environment, offline, or with our team

Where the other tools are the better choice

If you need review, use a review platform. Coding for privilege and responsiveness, numbering a production, writing load files and keeping a privilege log are what Relativity and Everlaw are built for, and PHI Mask does none of them. If the evidence is video or audio, CaseGuard covers what PHI Mask does not. If you have a handful of PDFs, a web service with a monthly plan is simpler than a batch.

Where PHI Mask Batch fits

PHI Mask Batch is for the set that is large and the job that is narrow: take the personal identifiers out of every document before the set is produced, shared with an expert or loaded for review. Medical records in a malpractice or injury case are the usual example. It runs offline in your environment or with our team, reads scans as it goes, keeps Bates numbers and the folder structure, and returns redacted copies with a release report of counts and hashes and a sample that people have read. The price is by the page and is printed on the page, so a litigation support manager can cost a matter before making a call.

Review before sharing.

Sources and review notes

Every statement about another product above comes from that vendor's own current documentation, reviewed on the date shown at the top of this page: Relativity's help pages for Redact, automated markup and spreadsheets, and its pricing page; Everlaw's help pages for redaction, batch redaction and spreadsheets; CaseGuard's product and pricing pages; and Redactable's file types, pricing and privilege log pages. Where a page is silent on a capability, this page does not guess. Products change quickly in this category, which is why this comparison carries a recheck date.

Common questions

Is PHI Mask a review platform?
No. It does not host a matter, code documents for privilege, number a production or write load files. It takes personal identifiers out of a document set and hands the set back.
Can it run before the set goes into our review platform?
Yes. The redacted copies come back in the same folder structure with Bates numbers kept, so the set loads into the platform you already use.
How is redaction priced in each kind of tool?
Review platforms price the platform, usually by data volume and on request. Desktop software is licensed by the user. Web services sell a monthly allowance of documents. PHI Mask Batch is priced by the page.
What about video and audio?
PHI Mask works on documents. CaseGuard documents redaction of video and audio as well as documents.